Managerial Motivation Dynamics and Incentives

Firms can increase profitability by appropriately motivating managers. We investigate drivers of managerial motivation, and propose how firms can use performance-pay to alter motivational patterns. We focus on the agent’s optimal effort decision in trading off compensation utility with effort cost in a static and dynamic setting. Surprisingly, we find that lower risk aversion or increased pay are not necessarily motivating factors, and identify the relevant effort drivers underlying the agent’s utility and compensation plan. We characterize properties of agents’ preferences for output lotteries (risk aversion, aggressiveness, prudence) that trigger systematic motivational patterns with respect to a variety of factors, such as agent’s productivity and past performance, time to evaluation, firm’s capabilities and market factors. Our insights are robust, holding under very general modeling assumptions on preferences, rewards and the stochastic effort-output function.